Joining Dissimilar Metals by Brazing — A Practical Guide for Engineers
Share
Dissimilar Metal Brazing
One of the most significant practical advantages of brazing over welding is its suitability for joining dissimilar metals. Where fusion welding typically requires base metals of compatible composition — and often produces brittle intermetallic phases at the joint when metals of different types are joined — brazing uses a separate filler metal that bonds metallurgically to both base metals without melting either of them. This makes it possible to produce strong, reliable joints between metals that would be very difficult or impossible to weld.
Dissimilar metal brazing is routine in refrigeration, HVAC, aerospace, automotive and general engineering. Understanding the principles involved — alloy selection, flux compatibility, thermal expansion and joint design — allows engineers to specify and execute these joints reliably.
Why Dissimilar Metal Joints Require Careful Specification
When two metals with different properties are joined, several factors need to be considered that do not arise with like-to-like joints.
Thermal expansion coefficients differ between metals. During brazing, the assembly is heated to brazing temperature and then cooled. If the two base metals expand and contract at significantly different rates, the joint experiences stress during the thermal cycle. In extreme cases — particularly where the joint area is large and the expansion mismatch is significant — this can cause joint cracking on cooling. For most common dissimilar metal combinations, the stress is manageable with appropriate joint design, but it should always be considered.
Flux compatibility varies with base metal. Some base metals, particularly stainless steel, nickel alloys and tungsten carbide, require specialist fluxes that are more aggressive than standard general-purpose grades. A flux that works well on copper and brass may be insufficient to remove the stable oxide layers present on these metals, resulting in poor wetting and incomplete joint fill.
Galvanic corrosion potential exists where two dissimilar metals are in contact in the presence of an electrolyte. This is a service condition rather than a brazing condition, but it is worth considering at the design stage — the joint configuration and any post-braze sealing or coating should take galvanic compatibility into account.
Common Dissimilar Metal Combinations and How to Braze Them
Copper to steel is one of the most frequently encountered dissimilar metal joints in engineering. The combination is straightforward to braze — silver brazing alloys bond well to both metals, and GS30 general-purpose flux handles the oxide conditions on both surfaces. AG103 (55% silver) is the recommended alloy for most copper-to-steel applications, giving excellent fluidity and a joint ductility that accommodates the modest thermal expansion mismatch between the two metals.
Copper to stainless steel requires more care. Stainless steel carries a tenacious chromium oxide layer that standard flux cannot adequately remove. Specify L-AG45SnSi or AG206 with Stay-Silv Black paste flux, which is formulated specifically for stainless steel and nickel alloys. Surface preparation of the stainless steel is more important than for mild steel — degrease thoroughly and avoid contamination of the stainless surface before brazing.
Steel to stainless steel follows the same principles as copper to stainless — the stainless surface drives the flux specification. Use Stay-Silv Black flux and an alloy with good flow on both surfaces. L-AG45SnSi is again the recommended choice for most applications.
Copper to brass is technically a dissimilar metal joint — brass is a copper-zinc alloy — but the properties are sufficiently similar that it is treated as a standard application. Any silver brazing alloy with GS30 flux is appropriate. Where colour match on the finished joint is important, AG104 at 45% silver provides the closest colour match to polished brass.
Tungsten carbide to steel is a demanding joint found in cutting tools, wear parts and specialist tooling. The carbide surface is extremely stable and requires aggressive fluxing — Stay-Silv Black is the minimum requirement, and some applications benefit from a pre-tinning operation on the carbide surface before the main brazing operation. AG103 or a high-silver grade is recommended for the joint itself to provide the ductility needed to accommodate the significant thermal expansion mismatch between carbide and steel.
Nickel alloy to steel or stainless steel joints arise in aerospace, chemical processing and high-temperature applications. The nickel alloy surface requires specialist flux — Stay-Silv Black — and the alloy selection should account for the service temperature and mechanical requirements. Contact our technical team for guidance on specific nickel alloy combinations.
Joint Design for Dissimilar Metal Brazing
For dissimilar metal joints involving significant thermal expansion mismatch, joint design can reduce the stress generated during the thermal cycle. Keeping the joint area small reduces the total expansion differential. Designing joints with some compliance — allowing the joint to flex slightly rather than transferring all stress to the brazed interface — improves fatigue life under thermal cycling. For tungsten carbide to steel joints specifically, a silver-copper interlayer or a ductile alloy with high silver content is used to provide a compliant layer that absorbs the expansion mismatch.
Standard capillary joint gaps of 0.05–0.2mm apply to dissimilar metal joints in the same way as like-to-like joints. The gap should be assessed when cold, taking into account the differential expansion of the two metals as they heat to brazing temperature — the gap that exists at room temperature will not be the same gap that exists at 650°C.
Practical Advice
When brazing dissimilar metals for the first time, trial joints on representative samples are strongly recommended before committing to production. The variables — flux activity, alloy flow, thermal expansion effects and joint fill — are best assessed on actual components rather than inferred from specification data alone.
If you are encountering problems with a dissimilar metal joint or are specifying a new application, our technical team can advise on alloy and flux selection based on your specific base metal combination, joint geometry and service requirements.
Contact our team for technical advice on dissimilar metal brazing.